Episode 23 - Carmel's Darkest Day

This week, we are taking you to Liam's hometown of Carmel, NY. It's the scene of a heartbreaking mystery that has plagued and divided us since it happened.

12-year-old Josette Wright was found bound and gagged in a wooded area in the Hudson River Valley. Almost right away, police say they've got their guys. But 30 years later, the town is still asking if they locked up the wrong people.

If you know anything about the murder of Josette Wright, call the Putnam County Sheriff's Department at 845-225-4300. And if you know anything about the disappearance of Robin Murphy, call the Carmel Police Department at 845-628-1300.

This week, we're drinking J. Lohr's Sauvignon Blanc.

Listen to Episode 23: Carmel's Darkest Day

SOURCES:

• The Devil You Know

• Who's who in Putnam murder case

• He Was Convicted of a 12-Year-Old’s Murder. Will a Retrial Prove His Innocence?

• ‘I'm Ready:' Man Faces High-Stakes Retrial in Murder of 12-Year-Old NY Girl

• Krivak retrial begins in 1997 murder of 12-year-old Putnam girl

• Defendant in 1994 Killing of NY Girl Gave Written Confession — But Was it Coerced?

• 'It's about time': Krivak acquitted in child's rape, murder after 24 years in prison

• Crime Scene: Robin Murphy missing 19 years

• Suspect in 1995 Putnam teen disappearance had her underwear

• 27 years ago, a 17-year-old girl vanished while visiting an older friend at the mall. Where is Robin Frances Murphy?

• The Charley Project: Robin Frances Murphy

• STATE v. GOMBERT (2003)